THE EFFECTIVENESS GROUP
  • HOME
    • OUR PHILOSOPHY
    • ABOUT US
    • SIGN UP
    • CONTACT US
  • WHAT WE DO
    • TRAINING >
      • CONVERSITY®
      • THE MEANINGFUL LEADER®
    • PERSONALITY
    • DiSC - AGILE EQ
    • KEYNOTE SPEAKING >
      • TOWARDS ACCEPTANCE
      • SLOW DOWN
      • MEANINGFUL LEADER
  • RESOURCES
    • INTERVIEWS
    • E-LEARNING >
      • FORM
    • ARTICLES >
      • 10 Ms OF ENGAGEMENT
      • A PERFECT MATCH
      • SEEKING COMMON GROUND
      • PERSONALITY MANUAL
      • PERSONAL SIDE OF ENGAGEMENT
      • ENGAGED TO SERVE
    • VIDEOS >
      • DECODING CHANGE
      • WHAT COULD GO WRONG
      • GLOBAL IMPACT OF YOU
      • FIT: CAREER & PERSONALITY
      • BiG FIVE INTRO
      • FORCE FIELD
      • PREDICTING ENGAGEMENT
      • ABILENE PARADOX
      • BAIRD'S ETHICAL LENSES
    • TOOLS >
      • CREATIVITY AND THEMES
      • ENERGY GAME
      • JEOPARDY
      • ROI CALCULATOR
  • BLOG
  • HOME
    • OUR PHILOSOPHY
    • ABOUT US
    • SIGN UP
    • CONTACT US
  • WHAT WE DO
    • TRAINING >
      • CONVERSITY®
      • THE MEANINGFUL LEADER®
    • PERSONALITY
    • DiSC - AGILE EQ
    • KEYNOTE SPEAKING >
      • TOWARDS ACCEPTANCE
      • SLOW DOWN
      • MEANINGFUL LEADER
  • RESOURCES
    • INTERVIEWS
    • E-LEARNING >
      • FORM
    • ARTICLES >
      • 10 Ms OF ENGAGEMENT
      • A PERFECT MATCH
      • SEEKING COMMON GROUND
      • PERSONALITY MANUAL
      • PERSONAL SIDE OF ENGAGEMENT
      • ENGAGED TO SERVE
    • VIDEOS >
      • DECODING CHANGE
      • WHAT COULD GO WRONG
      • GLOBAL IMPACT OF YOU
      • FIT: CAREER & PERSONALITY
      • BiG FIVE INTRO
      • FORCE FIELD
      • PREDICTING ENGAGEMENT
      • ABILENE PARADOX
      • BAIRD'S ETHICAL LENSES
    • TOOLS >
      • CREATIVITY AND THEMES
      • ENERGY GAME
      • JEOPARDY
      • ROI CALCULATOR
  • BLOG

Why I support HRCI

5/27/2014

5 Comments

 
Don't you hate it when two organizations you respect and enjoy are on opposite sides of the fence - and you feel that you have to "take sides"? I suppose this is one of those times. 

I do respect SHRM. In particular, I have had wonderful experiences with members of the Iowa SHRM Council Board and the Central Iowa SHRM. 

Over the last few years, however, (in my capacity as Director of Certification for the Iowa SHRM State Council) I have worked closely with the HRCI. I have become acquainted with their work and with the seriousness of their efforts. So yes - I am saddened (and considerably surprised) by the national SHRM's move to create its own certification. Here are my reasons:


1. Independence

Call me old fashioned but I like the idea of a "separation of powers" between those who develop and maintain a certification exam and those whose business model includes preparing candidates or providing recertification credits. Here is why:
  • Credibility - When the testing and the preparation/recertification phases are separate and independent, outside parties are more likely to trust the certification.
  • Access - There should not be a systemic bias towards someone who purchases  a particular set of materials, enrolls in course x, or completes webinar series y.  Candidates should be able to use a variety of materials and processes, according to their budget and preferences. In fact, teaching candidates to look for a wide range of materials and sources adds richness and value to the preparation process.

2. Continuity

SHRM has not yet shared with its members a strong enough reason to justify such a major shock to the system. Confused candidates or certified professionals may stop trusting the certification process in general, regardless of who offers it.

Do SHRM's hopes for a "competency based" test convince me? Not yet - at least not until I receive more in-depth information. The word "competency," after all, involves a complex combination of skills, traits, attitudes, and knowledge.  Is SHRM really going to test competencies? Or just knowledge of competencies? I guess we'll need to wait and see, but a truly valid and reliable competency based test is extremely hard to build.  SHRM might need to incorporate in the testing processes the review of real work products (an analysis of portfolios, perhaps?), and other time consuming (and likely costly) methods.

3. Secrecy

SHRM is our association - we, the members, should have a say in something as important as the launch of a new professional certification. Instead, SHRM chapters have been operating in the dark, working hard to promote the current certifications to employers and candidates. Frankly, I feel betrayed.

So here is my message to the national SHRM. You play a valuabl
e role to your members and to the HR field. Right now, however, you are sharing a poor example of strategic planning, communication, and cooperation.  HR professionals should be able to play nicely in the sandbox.

I wonder if these competencies will appear in the new certification exam? 

An important "postscript": I plan to keep my SPHR certification, which I very much value. I'm proud of this certification and grateful for all the doors it opened for me in the HR community. 

For the record, I do not plan to seek the new SHRM certification. In fact, the idea of "transferring" a certification (something SHRM has suggested) makes absolutely no sense (perhaps it only makes sense in the minds of marketing colleagues).  Do I plan to obtain further HRCI certifications? Absolutely - GPHR is next on my plans, as soon as I take care of tenure requirements at my university.




5 Comments
    Picture

    About the Author

    Dr. Cris Wildermuth is an Assistant Professor at Drake University, where she coordinates and teaches at the Master of Science in Leadership Development.

    A
    re you interested in receiving "Connections," our monthly newsletter? If so, please sign up by clicking here. Our promise to you: We never share your information with anyone else.

    Click here more issues of Dr. Wildermuth's blog (we used to publish it in a different address).

    Archives

    January 2021
    December 2020
    April 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    November 2014
    October 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014

    Categories

    All
    Authenticity
    Courage
    Creativity
    Csikszentmihalyi
    Dan McAdams
    Engagement
    Ethics
    Fairness
    Flow
    Gender And Leadership
    Hrci
    Impartiality
    Innovation
    Justice
    Leadership
    Life Stories
    Maleficent
    Personality
    Proximity
    Sheryl Sandberg
    Shrm

    RSS Feed

Home

WHAT WE DO

RESOURCES

BLOG

Contact

Copyright © 2020 The Effectiveness Group